Presenters/Discussants: Caspar Kaiser, David Reinstein, Valentin Klotzbücher
Reinstein/Klotzbücher introduce Caspar and the Unjournal process; Alberto Prati may contribute via pre-recorded video.
Overview
This segment features the Unjournal evaluators who assessed the Benjamin et al. paper. Caspar Kaiser will share key critiques and suggestions from the evaluation, followed by dialogue with the paper's authors (Benjamin, Kimball) and open discussion with all participants.
Structure
- Brief context on the Unjournal evaluation process, Pivotal Questions initiative, and how we're seeking evaluators for future PQ-related research
- Evaluator findings: strengths, limitations, methodological concerns
- Author responses and dialogue
- Practical applicability of the calibration approaches
- Areas where more research is needed